Active · Single Family

5125 SANDY BEACH AVENUE

SARASOTA, FL 34242

$1,295,000

$584/sqft

Beds

3 beds

Baths

2 baths

Area

2,216 sqft

Single FamilyBuilt 19689,427 sqft lotCentralCentral AirPool$584/sqft3 days on market

About this home

Island living begins here. Thoughtfully updated and meticulously maintained, this exceptional 2,216-square-foot, three-bedroom-plus-studio, two-bathroom residence seamlessly blends modern comforts with timeless coastal appeal in the heart of Siesta Key. From the moment you step through the front door, you're welcomed by a captivating view of the sparkling heated screened pool, setting the tone for a home designed to embrace effortless indoor-outdoor living. A desirable split-bedroom floor plan offers privacy and functionality, while porcelain tile flooring and impact-resistant windows and sliding glass doors enhance both comfort and peace of mind. The beautifully appointed kitchen features Cambria quartz countertops, a farmhouse sink, a gas cooktop, and a spacious island with additional storage, flowing seamlessly into the home's inviting living spaces. A charming shiplap-accented living room overlooks the tropical backyard, creating a warm and welcoming setting for everyday living and entertaining. Privately tucked away, the primary suite offers vaulted ceilings, French doors opening to the lanai, dual walk-in closets, and a spa-inspired bath with a classic cast-iron clawfoot soaking tub. Step outside to your private island retreat, where the heated screened pool is surrounded by Shell-Lock pool deck and coping, an outdoor shower, landscape lighting, a mature oak tree, Christmas palm, and multiple Areca palms, creating a tranquil setting complete with a hammock for relaxing in the coastal breeze. Adding to the home's versatility, a private studio with its own exterior entrance offers endless possibilities as a home office, creative studio, fitness room, guest suite, or additional sleeping quarters. Additional highlights include a tankless water heater, a high-efficiency HVAC system with infrared filtration, recessed LED lighting throughout, and exceptional attention to detail. Perfectly positioned in the heart of Siesta Key, this remarkable home offers convenient access to world-renowned Siesta Beach, Siesta Village, and downtown Sarasota.

Facts & features

Interior

Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 2
Living area: 2,216 sqft
Heating: Central
Cooling: Central Air
Flooring: Tile
Stories: 1
Features: Ceiling Fans(s), Eat-in Kitchen, Kitchen/Family Room Combo, Primary Bedroom Main Floor, Solid Surface Counters, Stone Counters…
Appliances: Built-In Oven, Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Gas Water Heater, Range Hood…

Exterior & lot

Lot size: 9,427 sqft (0.22 ac)
Pool: Yes
Roof: Shingle
Construction: Block, Stucco
Exterior: French Doors, Lighting, Outdoor Shower, Sliding Doors, Storage

Financial

Annual tax: $4,367 (2025)
Price / sqft: $584/sqft

Utilities

Water: Public
Sewer: Public Sewer
Utilities: Cable Connected, Electricity Connected, Propane, Public, Underground Utilities, Water Connected

Property

Property type: Single Family
Year built: 1968
Subdivision: SIESTA BEACH
County: Sarasota

Assigned schools

Elementary: Phillippi Shores Elementary
Middle: Brookside Middle
High: Sarasota High

Listing

Status: Active
Days on market: 1 day
MLS #: MFR801561842
Source: Stellar MLS

Listed by Victoria Turner · MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY

Listing data provided by Stellar MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

RRENA ValiQEstimate

Sample estimate — not an appraisal

$1.28M

−1.0% vs asking

$1.20M low$1.36M high

Based on 17 comparable sales within 2 miles of SARASOTA, FL. priced in line with RENA ValiQ.

Reference only. Estimates blend public sale comps, neighbourhood trend and the listing’s own metrics. Final price moves on diligence, terms and timing — RENA is your second read, not your agent.

Estimate your monthly cost

PITI + HOA

Down payment (%)

Interest rate (%)

Loan term (yrs)

Property tax (% / yr)

Home insurance ($ / yr)

HOA dues ($ / mo)

Estimated monthly payment$8,064/mo

Principal & interest: $6,893/mo
Property tax: $971/mo
Home insurance: $200/mo

Tax, insurance and HOA are editable estimates with Florida-typical defaults — Florida homeowners insurance in particular varies widely by location and elevation. Confirm exact figures with a lender and insurer.