Skip to content
4472 Lake Heather Circle, St James City, FL 33956

37 photos in the listing

4472 Lake Heather Circle

St James City, FL 33956 · Lee County

$425,000

2

Beds

2

Baths

1,248

Sq ft

1989

Year built

Location

About this home

Tired of South Florida's high home prices and traffic snarls? Relocate to bucolic Pine Island on Florida's Southwest Coast. Take a step back into Old Florida amidst soaring pine trees, hiking trails, spectacular sunsets, mango groves, and palm farms. This quiet, peaceful home offers lovely pastoral views on two sides, making you feel like you are in the middle of the country with unrestricted views of local farmland and cows. It is a true nature lover's paradise with more backyard birds than you will find on an Audubon walk. Yet, you are just moments away from a vibrant live music and art scene, great fishing, birding, boating, and ferry service to surrounding barrier islands. Set on 0.27 acres, this 1,500-square-foot property sits in a friendly neighborhood of about 40 homes with a low HOA. Residents enjoy amenities like a basketball court and a community pool that was recently improved. Virtually everything inside and out has been remodeled since 2018. The home features a two-bedroom, two-bathroom split floor plan that feels almost like having two primary suites, plus an ample den that could serve as a third bedroom while still leaving room for a study. The open layout boasts neutral interior paint, tile floors, and LED lighting throughout. The new kitchen and bathrooms showcase custom cabinetry, a large pantry, and tall, low-water-use toilets. An electric fireplace was recently added to the living room, which also benefits from a natural solar light. Solid core doors and ceiling fans in every room enhance the comfort of the home. The den, with large impact windows, functions as an extension of the main living space and is currently set up with two desk spaces, making it ideal for remote work. Even the garage is heated and air-conditioned, featuring custom cabinets and abundant inside storage. This home is built like a fortress when it comes to hurricanes, offering absolute peace of mind. Situated on one of the highest points on the island, it requires no flood insurance and experienced no flooding during recent storms. It is equipped with a new metal roof, hurricane-resistant windows, and a whole-house generator. Energy efficiency is a priority, resulting in low electric bills and low A/C costs. The exterior is designed for low-maintenance living, featuring a drought-resistant Provista grass lawn and an irrigation sprinkler system hooked up to a private well. Additional upgrades include covered and open patios, Leaf Filter gutters with buried drains, an antenna in the attic, an outside storage shed for garden supplies, and rainwater storage for inside plants.

Facts & features

Interior

Bedrooms
2
Bathrooms
2
Living area
1,248 sq ft
Stories
1
Flooring
Tile, Vinyl
Appliances
Dishwasher, Microwave, Range, Refrigerator
Features
Cathedral Ceiling(s), Ceiling Fans(s), Eat-in Kitchen, High Ceilings, Living Room/Dining Room Combo, Open Floorplan, Primary Bedroom Main Floor, Split Bedroom, Thermostat, Vaulted Ceiling(s), Walk-In Closet(s)
Fireplace
Yes
Cooling
Central Air
Heating
Natural Gas

Exterior & lot

Lot size
0.27 acres
Construction
Vinyl Siding, Frame
Roof
Metal
Features
Private Mailbox

Parking

Garage spaces
2

Financial

Price / sqft
$341/sqft
Annual tax
$4,198.59
Tax year
2025
HOA fee
$500
HOA billed
Annually

Utilities

Utilities
Cable Available, Electricity Connected, Water Connected
Water
Public
Sewer
Septic Tank

Property

Property type
Single Family
Year built
1989
Subdivision
Pine Island Village
Days on market
1 day

Estimate your monthly cost

Twenty percent down over thirty years at 6.5%. Insurance is not included.

Principal & interest
$2,149
Property tax
$350
HOA dues
$42
Estimated monthly
$2,541

Ask about this property

Answered from this listing’s own figures and the sales around it.

Similar homes nearby

Price history

From the property’s MLS record.

DateEventPriceChange
Oct 19, 2026Listed$425,000—

Neighbourhood

The schools below come from the MLS record for this home. Walking, transit and cycling figures for St James City, FL are not connected yet, so this page does not show them.

About this area

ST JAMES CITY, FL sits in Lee County. The MLS record names Pine Island Elementary (elementary), Gulf Middle School (middle), Ida S. Baker High School (high) as the assigned schools.

Written from this listing’s own record and the homes we hold nearby.

Elementary school
Pine Island Elementary
Assigned school from the MLS record
Middle school
Gulf Middle School
Assigned school from the MLS record
High school
Ida S. Baker High School
Assigned school from the MLS record

Frequently asked questions

What would 4472 LAKE HEATHER CIRCLE, ST JAMES CITY cost per month?

About $2,541 a month: $2,149 principal and interest, $350 property tax, $42 HOA. That assumes 20% down at 6.5% over 30 years, and leaves out insurance.

Is 4472 LAKE HEATHER CIRCLE, ST JAMES CITY priced fairly?

It is listed at $425,000. There are not enough comparable homes close by to put a range around that yet, so the asking price is the honest answer.

How does 4472 LAKE HEATHER CIRCLE, ST JAMES CITY compare to nearby homes?

1 comparable property within three miles. The nearest: 4501 ROYAL PALM RANCH DRIVE, ST JAMES CITY, FL at $995,000, 1,212 sq ft, 0.58 miles away.

How long has 4472 LAKE HEATHER CIRCLE, ST JAMES CITY been on the market?

It came on the market today.

Has the price of 4472 LAKE HEATHER CIRCLE, ST JAMES CITY changed?

The price has not moved since it was listed.

How big is 4472 LAKE HEATHER CIRCLE, ST JAMES CITY?

2 bed, 2 bath, 1,248 square feet. That is $341 a square foot.

What year was 4472 LAKE HEATHER CIRCLE, ST JAMES CITY built?

Built in 1989.

What is the HOA fee at 4472 LAKE HEATHER CIRCLE, ST JAMES CITY?

The association fee works out to $42 a month.

What are the property taxes at 4472 LAKE HEATHER CIRCLE, ST JAMES CITY?

Property tax works out to about $350 a month, $4,199 a year, on the 2025 assessment.

Is 4472 LAKE HEATHER CIRCLE, ST JAMES CITY still available?

It is still on the market.

Listing

Listed by
Melissa Patriarca
Brokerage
REDFIN CORPORATION
MLS number
MFR814366597

Listing information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed.