Under Contract$1,100,000
1251 ALABAMA AVENUE
LADY LAKE, FL 32159
3 beds3 baths3,053 sqft
Active · Single Family
5489 NANTAHALA LANE
LADY LAKE, FL 32159
Beds
3 beds
Baths
3 baths
Area
2,530 sqft
Single FamilyBuilt 2023214,934 sqft lot3-car garageCentralCentral AirPool$405/sqft31 days on market
Location
About this home
JUST UNDER 5 ACRES | NO HOA | HEATED SALTWATER POOL | WHOLE-HOUSE GENERATOR | 2 PRIMARY SUITES | 3-CAR GARAGE | WATER FILTRATION SYSTEM 2,500+ SQ FT! If you've been dreaming of country living without sacrificing the comforts and finishes you love, look no further! Situated on just under 5 acres with NO HOA, this nearly new 3-bedroom, 3-bath home offers over 2,500 sq. ft. of living space, a screened heated saltwater pool, whole-house generator, 3-car garage, and a desirable split floor plan featuring TWO PRIMARY SUITES! From the moment you arrive, the long brick-paver driveway, expansive property, and beautiful curb appeal set the stage for something special. Follow the brick-paver walkway to the welcoming front porch and step inside, where soaring ceilings, abundant natural light, and an open, spacious floor plan create an immediate WOW factor. A formal dining area and separate office/den provide flexibility for entertaining, working from home, or creating the space that fits your lifestyle. At the heart of the home, the kitchen was made for gathering, featuring granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a center island overlooking the family room. Oversized sliders seamlessly connect the indoor living space to your own Florida backyard retreat—a covered lanai and screened, HEATED SALTWATER POOL overlooking the expansive acreage! The covered patio is already plumbed for a permanent summer kitchen, while the additional brick-paver patio with firepit offers the perfect spot for evenings under the stars. Back inside, the split-bedroom layout provides exceptional privacy. Bedroom #2 functions as a SECOND PRIMARY SUITE with its own private bath featuring granite countertops and a walk-in shower—ideal for guests, extended stays, or multigenerational living. Bedroom #3 is located near the additional guest/pool bath, which features a tub/shower combination and convenient exterior access to the pool. Your spacious primary retreat offers tray ceilings, a sitting area, TWO walk-in closets with built-ins, and an impressive en-suite bath complete with dual granite-topped vanities, Jacuzzi soaking tub, and large walk-in shower. And there's more—a 3-CAR GARAGE, storage shed, plenty of room to park and enjoy your acreage, and a WHOLE-HOUSE GENERATOR providing added peace of mind during Florida's storm season. Whether you're dreaming of wide-open space, unforgettable pool days, entertaining family and friends, or simply enjoying a little more privacy, this property delivers the country lifestyle you've been searching for while keeping you conveniently close to THE VILLAGES, shopping, dining, entertainment, medical facilities, and everyday conveniences. Nearly new, beautifully appointed, and sitting on almost 5 acres with NO HOA—properties offering this combination of space, privacy, amenities, and location don't come along every day. Come experience it for yourself!
Facts & features
Interior
- Bedrooms
- 3
- Bathrooms
- 3
- Living area
- 2,530 sqft
- Heating
- Central
- Cooling
- Central Air
- Flooring
- Carpet, Laminate, Tile
- Stories
- 1
- Features
- Ceiling Fans(s), Eat-in Kitchen, Kitchen/Family Room Combo, Open Floorplan, Split Bedroom, Vaulted Ceiling(s)
- Appliances
- Dishwasher, Dryer, Range, Refrigerator, Washer, Water Filtration System
Exterior & lot
- Lot size
- 214,934 sqft (4.93 ac)
- Pool
- Yes
- Roof
- Shingle
- Construction
- Block, Stucco
Parking
- Garage
- 3 spaces
Financial
- Annual tax
- $9,600 (2025)
- Price / sqft
- $405/sqft
Utilities
- Water
- Well
- Sewer
- Septic Tank
- Utilities
- Underground Utilities
Property
- Property type
- Single Family
- Year built
- 2023
- Subdivision
- SHERYDAN GLENN SUB
- County
- Lake
Listing
- Status
- Active
- Days on market
- 31 days
- MLS #
- MFR803273303
- Source
- Stellar MLS
Listed by Kim Ducharme-Levensohn · MORRIS REALTY AND INVESTMENTS
Listing data provided by Stellar MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Estimate your monthly cost
PITI + HOAEstimated monthly payment$5,983/mo
- Principal & interest
- $5,183/mo
- Property tax
- $800/mo
- Home insurance
- Left out until you enter a quote
Opens at 20% down over 30 years at 6.5%, the same assumptions as the answers below. Property tax is this listing's own 2025 bill. Insurance is left out until you enter a quote, because Florida premiums turn on roof age, elevation and carrier. Every field is editable.
Ask about this property
Answered from this listing’s own figures and the sales around it.
Similar homes nearby
Homes for sale in LADY LAKE within the same price band.
Price history
From the property’s MLS record.
| Date | Event | Price | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 21, 2026 | Listed | $1,025,000 | — |
Neighbourhood
The schools below come from the MLS record for this home. Walking, transit and cycling figures for LADY LAKE, FL are not connected yet, so this page does not show them.
Elementary school
Not listed
Not named in the MLS record for this home
Middle school
Not listed
Not named in the MLS record for this home
High school
Not listed
Not named in the MLS record for this home
Frequently asked questions
What would 5489 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE cost per month?
About $5,983 a month: $5,183 principal and interest, $800 property tax. That assumes 20% down at 6.5% over 30 years, and leaves out insurance.
Is 5489 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE priced fairly?
Comparable homes nearby put it between $572,931 and $659,179, with $616,055 in the middle. Those are asking prices, not closed sales: 8 properties of the same type within three miles, each within 20% of this one's size and a bedroom either way, at a median of $244 a square foot.
How does 5489 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE compare to nearby homes?
8 comparable properties within three miles. The nearest: 5496 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE, FL at $1,250,000, 2,980 sq ft, 0.19 miles away; 5509 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE, FL at $1,100,000, 2,254 sq ft, 0.27 miles away; 39819 GROVE HEIGHTS, LADY LAKE, FL at $489,000, 2,504 sq ft, 0.66 miles away.
How long has 5489 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE been on the market?
7 days on the market.
Has the price of 5489 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE changed?
The price has not moved since it was listed.
How big is 5489 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE?
3 bed, 3 bath, 2,530 square feet. That is $405 a square foot.
What year was 5489 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE built?
Built in 2023.
What is the HOA fee at 5489 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE?
The feed lists no association fee for this property.
What are the property taxes at 5489 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE?
Property tax works out to about $800 a month, $9,600 a year, on the 2025 assessment.
Is 5489 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE still available?
It is still on the market.