Under Contract$1,100,000
1251 ALABAMA AVENUE
LADY LAKE, FL 32159
3 beds3 baths3,053 sqft
Active · Single Family
5509 NANTAHALA LANE
LADY LAKE, FL 32159
Beds
3 beds
Baths
4 baths
Area
2,254 sqft
Single FamilyBuilt 2023175,166 sqft lot2-car garageCentralCentral AirPoolFireplace$488/sqft96 days on market
Location
About this home
Custom-Built 4 Bedroom, 3.5 Bath Pool Home on 4.2 Acres with Saltwater Pool, 40x40 RV Pole Barn, Loft & Every Bedroom Featuring a Private Bath! Follow the winding country roads to a place where breathtaking sunsets, open skies, & peaceful country living create the life you've been dreaming of. Nestled on 4.2 beautifully fenced acres & surrounded by 4-board fencing, this custom-built estate offers the perfect balance of privacy & tranquility while remaining just minutes from everyday conveniences. The moment you arrive through the electric gated entrance, you'll immediately appreciate the attention to detail & thoughtful design that set this property apart. Extended driveway welcomes you while the front porch greets you as you enter the home. As the sun begins to set the property transforms into a private retreat where wide-open views & colorful skies become part of your daily routine. Step inside & discover a home designed for both comfort & elegance. Soaring ceilings, natural light, custom trim work, upgraded lighting, & stunning Old English wood flooring create a warm and inviting atmosphere. The open-concept design seamlessly blends the living, dining, & kitchen spaces, making the home ideal for entertaining & everyday living. Anchoring the great room is a stunning floor-to-ceiling rock accent wall featuring an LED fireplace, creating a beautiful focal point & cozy gathering space. Kitchen is both functional & beautiful, featuring quartz countertops, full-height designer backsplash, stainless appliances, & an island perfect for preparing meals or gathering. Lg windows & french doors frame views of the pool & brings the outdoors in. The luxurious primary suite feels like a private spa retreat. Custom closet system & an impressive ensuite bath showcasing upgraded cabinetry, quartz counters, upgraded fixtures, a freestanding soaking tub, walk-in shower, & upgraded bidet. Each of the home's bedrooms offers exceptional comfort, & a rare feature buyers will appreciate—every bedroom has direct access to a private bath creating the perfect setup. Upstairs, a spacious loft provides incredible flexibility & can easily serve as an office, hobby, or additional living space to fit your lifestyle. Outdoor living reaches another level w/ the spectacular screened saltwater pool & spa. Spend your days relaxing in the pool, unwind in the hot tub, or gather around one of the 2 fire pits that beautifully frame the spa area. Oversized brick paver deck offers plenty of room for entertaining, & enjoying Florida's year-round sunshine. Pool automation controlled directly from your phone allows you to manage the pool & spa w/ ease. Beyond the home, the property offers flexibility for RV owners, boat enthusiasts, or anyone needing additional storage. The 40x40 pole barn features a 14-ft clear entry & provides ample room for RVs, boats, & more. Additional upgrades include RV & generator hookups, whole-house water softener, upgraded closets throughout, & numerous custom features that reflect quality craftsmanship & pride of ownership. Whether you're enjoying quiet evenings watching the sunset from the welcoming front porch, hosting around the pool, parking your RV under the oversized pole barn, or simply taking in the beauty of the surrounding countryside, this property offers a lifestyle that is becoming increasingly difficult to find. Experience the peace of country living without sacrificing convenience—just minutes from The Villages and everyday amenities.
Facts & features
Interior
- Bedrooms
- 3
- Bathrooms
- 4
- Living area
- 2,254 sqft
- Heating
- Central
- Cooling
- Central Air
- Flooring
- Tile, Wood
- Fireplace
- Yes
- Stories
- 1
- Features
- Ceiling Fans(s), Eat-in Kitchen, High Ceilings, Kitchen/Family Room Combo, Open Floorplan, Primary Bedroom Main Floor…
- Appliances
- Cooktop, Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Microwave, Range…
Exterior & lot
- Lot size
- 175,166 sqft (4.02 ac)
- Pool
- Yes
- Roof
- Shingle
- Construction
- Block, Concrete
- Exterior
- French Doors, Private Mailbox, Rain Gutters
Parking
- Garage
- 2 spaces
Financial
- Annual tax
- $8,629 (2025)
- Price / sqft
- $488/sqft
Utilities
- Water
- Well
- Sewer
- Septic Tank
- Utilities
- Cable Available
Property
- Property type
- Single Family
- Year built
- 2023
- Subdivision
- SHERYDAN GLENN SUB
- County
- Lake
Listing
- Status
- Active
- Days on market
- 96 days
- MLS #
- MFR793858138
- Source
- Stellar MLS
Listed by Kim Ducharme-Levensohn · MORRIS REALTY AND INVESTMENTS
Listing data provided by Stellar MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Estimate your monthly cost
PITI + HOAEstimated monthly payment$6,281/mo
- Principal & interest
- $5,562/mo
- Property tax
- $719/mo
- Home insurance
- Left out until you enter a quote
Opens at 20% down over 30 years at 6.5%, the same assumptions as the answers below. Property tax is this listing's own 2025 bill. Insurance is left out until you enter a quote, because Florida premiums turn on roof age, elevation and carrier. Every field is editable.
Ask about this property
Answered from this listing’s own figures and the sales around it.
Similar homes nearby
Homes for sale in LADY LAKE within the same price band.
Price history
From the property’s MLS record.
| Date | Event | Price | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 19, 2026 | Price reduced | $1,100,000 | −$100,000 |
| Jun 17, 2026 | Listed | $1,200,000 | — |
Neighbourhood
The schools below come from the MLS record for this home. Walking, transit and cycling figures for LADY LAKE, FL are not connected yet, so this page does not show them.
Elementary school
Not listed
Not named in the MLS record for this home
Middle school
Not listed
Not named in the MLS record for this home
High school
Not listed
Not named in the MLS record for this home
Frequently asked questions
What would 5509 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE cost per month?
About $6,281 a month: $5,562 principal and interest, $719 property tax. That assumes 20% down at 6.5% over 30 years, and leaves out insurance.
Is 5509 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE priced fairly?
Comparable homes nearby put it between $459,072 and $528,180, with $493,626 in the middle. Those are asking prices, not closed sales: 8 properties of the same type within three miles, each within 20% of this one's size and a bedroom either way, at a median of $219 a square foot.
How does 5509 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE compare to nearby homes?
8 comparable properties within three miles. The nearest: 5489 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE, FL at $1,025,000, 2,530 sq ft, 0.27 miles away; 40044 AGUSTA DRIVE, LADY LAKE, FL at $422,000, 1,826 sq ft, 0.48 miles away; 5013 HARBOR HEIGHTS, LADY LAKE, FL at $330,000, 1,954 sq ft, 0.62 miles away.
How long has 5509 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE been on the market?
60 days on the market.
Has the price of 5509 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE changed?
It has gone down from $1,200,000 to $1,100,000, a change of -8.3%.
How big is 5509 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE?
3 bed, 4 bath, 2,254 square feet. That is $488 a square foot.
What year was 5509 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE built?
Built in 2023.
What is the HOA fee at 5509 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE?
The feed lists no association fee for this property.
What are the property taxes at 5509 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE?
Property tax works out to about $719 a month, $8,629 a year, on the 2025 assessment.
Is 5509 NANTAHALA LANE, LADY LAKE still available?
It is still on the market.